Alicia Mahon
Alicia Mahon

Alicia Mahon

Licensed Real Estate Salesperson

Member of The Susan Santoro Team
  • M
102 B Broad Street
Guilford, CT 06437

About Me About Me

Alicia Mahon, an integral member of The Susan Santoro Team, consistently achieves top rankings in New Haven County and along the shoreline for dollar volume, having successfully sold over $75 million in 2022 and Recently named the #1 Team  in Dollar Volume & Units company-wide. As a dedicated full-time real estate agent, Alicia adeptly represents buyers, sellers, and investors. Leveraging her background in the home remodeling industry, she garners praise from clients for her extensive knowledge, unwavering availability, and commitment to executing each transaction with professionalism, always prioritizing the best interests of her clients.

Alicia's primary objective is to deliver high-quality customer service and manage real estate transactions efficiently. She is known for crafting distinctive marketing strategies for sellers, ensuring exposure across various media platforms. Alicia's proactive nature, meticulous attention to detail, and genuine passion for the industry contribute to successful transitions for buyers, particularly in complex "sell and buy" scenarios where precise timing is crucial for a seamless move.

Beyond her dedication to real estate, Alicia finds joy in devoting time to her family and actively participating in the local community.

Alicia has been regularly awarded for her production.
New Haven Middlesex Board of Realtor Quarterly Production Award
Gold Award Winner 
Platinum Award Winner 
Five Star award in Connecticut Magazine 2022 & 2023

Sponcer of Guilford Fund for Education
The Susan Santoro Team- voted Top Real Estate Group by New Haven Living Magazine
Volunteering for organizations including The Ronald McDonald House and Yale New Haven Hospital and
a member of the American Heart Association Advocate and Sponsor.

You can find Alicia supporting multiple youth programs along the shoreline.

  • Born In New Haven County
  • Lives In Guilford
  • Passion Real Estate
  • Interests Coffee, Reading, Basketball, Softball, Gardening, Cooking , Boating, Kayaking, Cooking, Traveling
  • Can't Live Without A Book-
512 Lake

Agent Designations

  • Military Relocation Professional
  • Licensed Real Estate Salesperson
Alicia Mahon photo 1
Alicia Mahon photo 2
Alicia Mahon photo 3
Alicia Mahon photo 4
Alicia Mahon photo 5
Alicia Mahon photo 6
Alicia Mahon photo 7
Alicia Mahon photo 8
Alicia Mahon photo 9
Alicia Mahon photo 10

My Listings and Sales

Loading listings...

Testimonials (40)

Alicia started as my realtor, became my trusted advisor, and has quickly become my friend. Her eternally vigilant focus on our needs and objectives, combined with her relationships and impressive network, are just a few reasons she is the unparalleled best choice for families deciding where to make meaningful moments, and investors diversifying into real estate. I’ve worked with quite a few realtors on the shoreline, including a few friends in the field, and no one holds a candle to Alicia and her team. She is, quite simply, the best. Marc Fafard
Draft Alicia started as my realtor, became my trusted advisor, and has quickly become my friend. Her eternally vigilant focus on our needs and objectives, combined with her relationships and impressive network, are just a few reasons she is the unparalleled best choice for families deciding where to make meaningful moments, and investors diversifying into real estate. I’ve worked with quite a few realtors on the shoreline, including a few friends in the field, and no one holds a candle to Alicia and her team. She is, quite simply, the best. Marc Fafard
Alicia was a huge help during this process of buying a home. She not only showed us homes. She helped us understand the market, understand how to put in a proper offer, and was there for us (me especially) when we found out we did not get a house. She was more than a realtor. You can tell that she cares for her clients, its more than a job to her. I would recommend anyone to Alicia when purchasing a home. At the end of it all Alicia helped us secure a beautiful home for a great price in a wonderful neighborhood. Diamond Davila Andre Cowles
Alicia is hands down the best real estate agent we could have ever asked for. When my partner and I decided that it was time to buy our forever home, Alicia was there with us every step of the way and we can’t imagine going through the home buying process without her. She was patient, responsive, incredibly knowledgeable, and very flexible with our hectic schedules. Her expertise in the local real estate market is second to none, and she’s a master at crafting the perfect offer to stand out in this insanely competitive market. We intend on recommending her to everyone we know who is looking to buy or sell in CT! Damon Gray Erin Shanley
We met Alicia about two years ago when we were looking for our first home. She helped us navigate a difficult buyers market at the time and find our dream home. About a year and a half after finding out dream home, life changed and we needed to move to the shoreline. Alicia again helped us through an even more difficult buyers market to find a house that we will be at for many years to come. She also helped us make an incredible profit on our sale. Her advice and counsel is always thoughtful and helpful. We will continue to recommend and use Alicia in the future. James & Daniella Golicz
Excellent work with you guys, Alicia Mahon thank you so much for your cooperation!! It was good experience! Aftab Mushtaq
Alicia was great throughout our search and buying process. She was very patient and was very quick to understand what we were looking for. Alicia would always promptly give us a call or respond to messages whenever we had a question or concern. And throughout the buying process Alicia would constantly keep us updated. We highly recommend Alicia! Andrew Wynn Claire Vaughan
Alicia went above and beyond to help my husband and I purchase our first home. She was flexible with our hectic schedules and helped us navigating purchasing a home quickly from states away. We would recommend her to everyone! Casey Webster
Exceptional 👍🙏 Anthony Mansi
GREAT TEAM Could not have done it without them 😎🙏 Anthony Mansi
Alicia was incredible to work with! We have worked with numerous buyers agents and Alicia has been by far the best and unlikely to be surpassed! She was incredibly attentive, communicative, timely and proactive. After spending time with us to hear what we were looking for she suggested areas and homes and laid out the pros/cons. She proactively texted or emailed daily with updates. Once we wanted to make an offer she nailed how to craft the offer, guided us stress free through the inspections and contingencies and since closing has been providing awesome recommendations for floor refinished, painters, handymen etc. We feel so lucky to have found Alicia and will recommend her to all our friends! Daniel Hugo Rolotti Kirsten Heinrich
Alicia Mahon is a wonderful real estate agent. She is extremely knowledgeable about the entire real estate selling/buying process. We value her advice. She is professional and also cares about her clients. We are so happy with the entire experience and thank Alicia for guiding us through it. Robert & Donna Carranzo
Alicia was a true professional to work with. She provided honest feedback and the guidance required during the sales process to sell the property in a timely manner and maximize my return. Thank you for all your help and I would recommend Alicia to anyone needing assistance buying or selling a home!! Craig Tracz
Alicia was extremely helpful in selling our house, and our search for a new one! She is very knowledgeable about the local market and was always responsive to our questions. Lianne
Very attentive very helpful highly recommend to anyone. Heriberto Martinez
My fiancée and I recently worked with Alicia to purchase a home as we concurrently are working to plan our wedding and I cannot say enough good about our experience. At every step of the way, Alicia worked tirelessly to make a bumpy process as smooth as possible for us. She was friendly, diligent, available when we needed her, was as tough as a bulldog when obstacles arose, and I can say with 100% confidence that we would not have been able to buy the perfect house for us without her assistance. Alicia is a very warm person, was always upbeat and helpful (even when we would have tried any average person's patience), and has a deep pool of experience that made her an indispensable resource for us when we had questions or concerns. Please rely on Alicia to help you as well with your next home sale or purchase. Ben, Hi Ben,
Alicia Mahon is an outstanding and exceptional agent. She continually went out of her way, always keep us up to date on everything and always responded promptly to any of our inquiries. You couldn’t ask for a better agent and we would highly recommend her Steven & Kathy Graubart
I have been working with Alicia for roughly 4 years now and i honestly dont know how she handles the work load and stays on top of everything the way she does. She has made every transaction for me extremely painless and has far exceeded every expectation i have ever had for a real estate agent. She recently helped me sell a rental property which required day to day communications not only with me but with the buyers agent/attorney/client, the tenants on the property and my attorney. I think most real estate agents would have gotten very annoyed with the amount of work that was at hand but Alicia handled it all professionally and with a smile. She is more than knowledgeable in this market and will always set the right expectations with your best interest in mind. I have never trusted an agent so much in my line of business as i do with Sotheby's and more specifically Alicia Mahon. Thank you for once again coming through amazingly Alicia! William Rose Stockbridge Properties
Alicia made buying a home in a difficult market a great experience. When something came on that she knew I would be interested in seeing she called me right away to schedule a showing. It is because of her professionalism, attention to detail, and diligence that she found a place that is perfect for me. I highly recommend Alica to anyone looking to buy or list their home. Thanks Alicia! BM, Branford Brian McCullagh
Alicia was efficient, organized and prepared. She helped me secure a rental so my child could finish high school during a very competitive market with low inventory. It was not an easy task with inventory so low and outrageous prices. We had all the paperwork completed and ready to present at time of showing ! Thanks to you Alicia! Jodi McCullagh
Alicia was terrific!! We were first-time home buyers, and Alicia very patiently walked us through all the many steps involved, from start to finish. She also gave us great tips of things to do in the area. We would definitely recommend her to future home buyers looking in the area. Jennifer Whiston Gert Bue Larsen
Alicia was more than helpful in buying our 1st multifamily property. She was extremely professional, open, transparent, and reliable through the whole process. She advocated for us and understood our needs. She is extremely communicative and easy to reach to answer any questions at all. We couldn’t have asked for a better agent during this process! JaQuay & Staysha
Alicia was tremendous..She worked extra hard on my behalf which made me feel more comfortable. She was always in charge and worked tirelessly which resulted in a sale. Richard Becker
I have worked with Alicia on close to 40 total transactions for both buying and selling and i have never been happier. Alicia is extremely knowledgeable in her field, responsive, and works with a sense of urgency. If you're looking to have an agent represent you to help ease all of your worries during the stressful times of buying or selling real estate, Alicia is top notch! Thanks for all you do Alicia! Stockbridge Properties, LLC
Alicia was fantastic in every stage of the home buying process. From working with us to find our home, to putting our offer in, to closing, she provided excellent advice and help. We would, and have, recommended Alicia to friends and family, or anyone looking to buy or sell. Jason & Daniella Golicz
Alicia was an amazing real estate agent, and was very helpful throughout the process. As a first time homebuyer, she walked us through all the considerations and factors we should think about, and gave us guidance from start to finish. Thanks Alicia for all your time and effort through this process! Vijaya & Divya Krishnan
From beginning to end, our experience with Alicia Mahon was fantastic! I highly recommend Alicia and William Pitt Sotheby’s to anyone considering a move. Jason & Deborah Ciero
Alicia was fantastic! She was helpful, knowledgeable, and always available to answer questions for us. She made our selling and buying experience stress-free and enjoyable. I would highly recommend Alicia to anyone looking to buy or sell a home. Jason & Deborah Cicero
Alicia is very professional and helped me a lot, not only in the process of property purchasing, but also in the previous apartment rental. Martin
Alicia represented me on purchasing my first home and she was awesome! She quickly responded to any questions I had, and made the whole process painless! I will be using her for any future home purchases! Michele Gambardella
Wonderful! David & Kelly McSergi
After my very first conversation with Alicia, I knew I was in the right hands for finding my perfect house! She listened carefully to all my hopes and needs for a suitable living space. As a nervous, first-time buyer, she guided and reassured me through every step, throughly answering all my questions. Her promptness and attention to detail ensured that the home buying process went very smoothly. I feel so fortunate to have had her as my realtor. I’m grateful every day for the amazing home I now live in thanks to her dedication and support! I highly recommend her as a realtor to anyone looking to find a new home. Alicia is not only an amazingly motivated and organized realtor, but also a compassionate and sincere individual. She gets the job done and makes the journey along the way enjoyable! Julie Larsen
Alicia is an amazing realtor!!!! She found us our home in a few months and it is perfect. She was always available and helped us with every single questions as we had lots as first time home owners. I have recommended her to everyone I know looking to buy. We consider Alicia more than our realtor, but our friend! Alicia, you are absolutely amazing! Jaclyn Torres
I have been working with Alicia for numerous years now and continue to do so for many reasons. Alicia has represented me on numerous real estate deals both buying and selling. She has shown right from the start that she is extremely competent in real estate transactions. I loved how she quickly responded to all of my questions as well as her knowledge of the whole process from start to finish. Finally, Alicia is very well respected in the real estate community and I think that goes a long way when it comes to negotiations. I wouldnt consider using anyone else. William Rose
She was awesome! Would definitely recommend her to family and friends. She is the best and I love my new home! Sean Corry
Great service, always available to answer questions and walk you through the process. Alicia was incredibly patient and helpful. We would recommend again in a heartbeat! Ryan MacLeod
Susan & Alicia encouraged us to sell our condo before we found our home. It was scary at first but they ensured us this was the best way to buy in a very fast moving market. They were 100% correct and although it was scary, it all worked out well beyond anything we could of hoped for! They understand the market, the tips and tricks and how to ease your mind. We found the perfect home and won the bidding war being so well prepared! Thank you for all your guidance and support to get us to the finish line! Angelo & Amy Vitale
Alicia was great to work with and she took care of all my real estate needs. Craig Tracz
Working with Alicia made the process of buying my condo as easy as it possibly could have been. She is extremely professional and helped stay on top of everything every step of the way. If anyone I know is looking to buy or sell a property Sotheby's will be my absolute TOP recommendation. Thank you! William Rose Stockbridge Properties, LLC
I had the pleasure of working with Alicia. She showed multiple houses, answered all my questions, helped to find my future house, submitting an offer, walked through the process of buying a house till closing. I am extremely happy with my experience and would highly recommend Alicia to my friends and family members. Majed Albache

Alicia Mahon in the News


Sophisticated Waterfront Living in East Haven…    


Elegant Contemporary Comfort…    


New England Charm Merges Modern Updates…    


GFFE Bee Ball Tournament a Success…


Popular Pizzeria For Sale, Chance To Own Slice Of History In CT…


Boston Post Road Office Space Leased…

Contact Me

  • Alicia Mahon

    Alicia Mahon

    Licensed Real Estate Salesperson
  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

  • Contact