Stacey Wyeth

Stacey Wyeth

Realtor ®

Niantic Brokerage

24 Pennsylvania Ave
Niantic, CT 06357
  • Born In:
    East Haddam, CT
  • Live In:
    Niantic, CT
  • Favorite Movie:
    The sound of music
  • Interests:
    I love the beach, hiking with my family and dogs, hitting the open road with my husband on the Harley, Halloween haunted houses, Traveling
  • Can’t Live Without:
    My family, beach sand between my toes, my fur babies and my yeti mug

Born & raised in Connecticut, I have lived up and down the CT Coast and CT River Valley. I have always loved the beach and I was very lucky to have the opportunity to make Niantic my home. Let me be your guide to the shoreline and river valley real estate market while helping you to buy or sell your investment, summer or primary residence!

Call on me to be your helping hand throughout & beyond the buying and selling process.. Certified SRS (seller representative specialist), RENE (real estate negotiation expert) , RSPS (resort & 2nd home property specialist) MRP ( military relocation professional) CLHMS ( certified luxury home marketing Specialist & your local DAVE RAMSEY ELP (endorsed local provider)  I look forward to working with you!

Born & raised in Connecticut, I have lived up and down the CT Coast and CT River Valley. I have always loved the beach and I was very lucky to have the opportunity to make Niantic my home. Let me be your guide to the shoreline and river valley real estate market while helping you to buy or sell your investment, summer or primary residence!

Call on me to be your helping hand throughout & beyond the buying and selling process.. Certified SRS (seller representative specialist), RENE (real estate negotiation expert) , RSPS (resort & 2nd home property specialist) MRP ( military relocation professional) CLHMS ( certified luxury home marketing Specialist & your local DAVE RAMSEY ELP (endorsed local provider)  I look forward to working with you!

Born & raised in Connecticut, I have lived up and down the CT Coast and CT River Valley. I have always loved the beach and I was very lucky to have the opportunity to make Niantic my home. Let me be your guide to the shoreline and river valley real estate market while helping you to buy or sell your investment, summer or primary residence!

Call on me to be your helping hand throughout & beyond the buying and selling process.. Certified SRS (seller representative specialist), RENE (real estate negotiation expert) , RSPS (resort & 2nd home property specialist) MRP ( military relocation professional) CLHMS ( certified luxury home marketing Specialist & your local DAVE RAMSEY ELP (endorsed local provider)  I look forward to working with you!

Read Less

Read MoreRead Less
  • Agent Designations
    • Seller Representative Specialist
    • Resort and Second Home Property Specialist
    • Certified Negotiation Expert
    • Military Relocation Professional
    • Licensed Real Estate Salesperson
  • Awards
    • Favorite Realtor runner up Readers Choice Award 2019
    • Sotheby's Gold Award for sales 2018 & Platinum Award for 2019 & 2020
    • #1 agent for Old Lyme in volume & dollar for 2019
    • #1 agent in Old Lyme in units, 2020
    • #7 agent company-wide for volume, 2019
    • #8 agent company-wide in units, 2020
    • #2 agent in Old Lyme in Rentals, 2020
  • Specialities
    • Dave Ramsey endorsed local provider
    • Certified luxury home marketing specialist
    • Official member of the Niantic Lions Club


Stacey Wyeth was absolutely wonderful though buying our new home and selling the old. She was always helpful and considerate of our needs above and beyond the call of duty. We would highly recommend her and Southebys to anyone.

James and Donna Flatley

The realty company, as well as the agent, exceeded my expectations and exhibited a high degree of professionalism throughout the entire selling process.

David Mamula

Stacey was extremely helpful throughout the whole process. We looked at what I was looking for and a few back up places cause the market was crazy! I really appreciated her looking out for me if my first choice didn't pan out. She never pulled any punches and let me know up front if a property was not going to work out for the budget I had. Would definitely recommend to my friends and colleagues!!

Jacob T Roch

Super job by Stacey!!!!

Brien Horan as trustee of Horan Family

Stacey is very knowledgeable and responds quickly to any issues, also has a great human element to her. She helped me buy and sell my last home. If she moves to Tennessee she’ll help me buy my next one. Can’t say enough good things.

David and Heidi Garrett

We worked with Samantha Stockel, and her dedication to selling our home was remarkable. Not only would I recommend her to my friends, I have! She sold their house as well!

John Faulkner

I have worked with Stacey Wyeth on several occasions both buying and selling property. Stacey is experienced, knowledgeable and calm under pressure. She has earned my complete confidence and my total trust. I won't work with anyone else.

Thomas Teixeira

Samantha Stockel was absolutely fantastic!! She held my hand through a long crazy process, answered all my questions and went above and beyond to sell my home. Samantha was everything you’d ever want or need in a realtor and I can’t stop telling everyone to use her!!

Paul Picken and Shannon Daley Piken and Daley

Stacey was incredibly supportive in our search for an accessible home. We will use her to sell our older home.

James P and Donna K Flatley

We were very pleased with the representation we had with Stacey Wyeth and the exposure we had when our house went on the market (both times)! Stacey was extremely responsive no matter when we had a question. The photography was truly spectacular and made our home stand out from all the others in our price range! It was always a vision of ours that Sotheby's would sell our house when the time came, and our vision became reality! Thank you Sotheby's! Frank and Tracey Florio

Frank and Tracey Florio

Stacey did an outstanding job, going above and beyond in this challenging market. Her experience and professionalism really made the difference for our hunt for a house in our chosen area. Thanks to her diligence, I was able to purchase a home that is perfect for my son and myself. I will certainly recommend her services in the future!

Diane E Deedy

Stacey was extremely helpful and quick to respond during my whole process! As a first time home buyer, she answered all of my questions and took the time to explain the process to me.

Leah Frascarelli

Stacey was amazing. I have never had a better realtor experience. She was extremely responsive, knowledgeable, pleasant and helpful. The purchase went through without a hitch. She was a trusted advisor throughout the process providing names of contacts for the inspection, financing, repairs to be made after sale, etc. She kept checking in and made sure all parties were taking the necessary steps to close the deal in a timely manner. I have already referred her to my sister who also purchased her home from Stacey. I would recommend Stacey without reservation to anyone looking for a home in the Niantic, Old Saybrook area.

Gail Bergmiller

Much of the sale of my mom's condo was done long distance. Stacey is extremely knowledgeable and made us feel extremely comfortable with the process, provided continuous updates and really made everything smooth and stress free! She is simply the best!

Therese Jourdan

Stacy Wyeth is an awesome realtor, I would recommend her to everyone I know who's selling a home. She went above and beyond in selling my home, she spearheaded and coordinated the team of contractors when I had to deploy to my new out of state job. She is a person that can be trusted to do the right thing by her customer. Hats off to you Stacy, you truly are an example to be followed.

Melvin Hicks

Stacey made selling my aunts house so easy during a difficult time. She always goes above and beyond to help her clients. She knows what she’s doing and she does it with a personal touch.

Estate of Lydia Ritchie

When the time came to sell my aunt's estate home we wanted to go with a Dave Ramsey Endorsed Local Provider (ELP). Stacey Wyeth was one of the names provided to us. She got in touch with us the same day as we submitted the request and we set up an appointment to meet. When we met up at the estate home, Stacey was very friendly and informative on what her role would be if we were to sign up with Sotheby's. After answering all our questions, we decided to have Stacey act as our selling agent. Stacey did a great job acting on our behalf in getting the home sold. We live in Florida, so we did most of the in-between correspondence by phone and mail. The house had a pending offer the day it went on the market and closed very quickly. We appreciate the time and effort that Stacey put in to get this sold, especially with us residing out of state. Thank you Stacey!

Estate of Mary E Monahan

Thank you!

Hunter Moss, Alexandra Skates

Stacey helped me sale my town house in Norwich CT and buy a new one in Groton CT. Given the stress that comes with selling and buying homes, my circumstances made it bit harder because I was not physically in the country given the COVID19 pandemic. Stacey handled everything from start to finish making this process stress free. She even went a step further by offering her husband’s service to remove the satellite dish from the roof, fixing the rails in the bathroom at no charge and found renters for my new home. She was both professional and personally invested in this project. Subject matter expert, great communication, real and honest advise all in the benefit of her customer. Stacey the best Real Estate agent hands down that I have had the pleasure working with. I would definitely work with her again and have already recommend her to a friends.

Martine Thurlow

Stacey was great, she exceeded our expectations. We matched with Stacey on a Zillow request to see a home. After Stacey showed us that house and two other similar homes, we decided to continue using Stacey as she is friendly, has a positive attitude, and did not just push for a sale but wanted us to find a great home! Stacey was available at a moments notice and extremely quick to respond throughout the entire home buying process. I highly recommend Stacey to anyone looking to buy or sell a home!!

Evan and Rebecca L. Tallarita

Stacey Wyeth worked tirelessly to sell my house.

Donna Lane

Stacey Wyeth is an amazing realtor. She always goes the “extra mile” to assure that the stress and chaos of selling a home is as easy as possible. I have had her as a buyer’s agent in the past and listed my home with her as well. I can plainly see both sides of her ability to provide excellent service and outstanding support. I highly recommend her services and would greatly encourage anyone looking to buy or sell a home to contact her for her services. You will not regret the decision to work with Stacey. She will always go above and beyond to meet your needs and exceed your expectations. Shelly Avery

Michele Avery

We have asked Stacey to help us several times with our real estate transactions. We have sold, purchased, and rented many properties and wouldn't think to ask any other realtor but Stacey Wyeth. She gets results/contracts usually within two weeks of our listing! She is pretty amazing and highly recommended!

This is the third time Stacey represented me in either the buying or selling of a residence and each time she hit it out of the park..!! A true professional in every sense of the word, she is at the top of her profession - hands down. Stacey goes the extra mile and gets results every time. Look no  further - she is the realtor you need, and want..!!

Stacey is a phenomenal realtor, and would highly recommend her. As first-time home buyers, Stacey helped us throughout the entire process by answering questions, making recommendations, and helping to push things along. We had a tight schedule, and needed to close quickly; Stacey helped this happen.

Stacey was absolutely amazing throughout the entire process of buying our home. She was timely in getting back to us and extremely knowledgeable! She is great to work with :) would highly recommend her to anyone looking for an agent. 

Home Buyer in East Haddam

After 25 years in my home, the letting go process wasn't easy. Stacey made everything as painless as possible for me! Even reminding me to take a breathe and that we had an end goal in mind, which she helped me to visualize when I was unsure! Available and with me every step of the way, the  process was smooth and the professionalism excellent. My home sold in less than 48 hours on the market! I highly recommend Stacey!

Home Seller in Salem

Stacey is the best. She has tenacity and a willingness to do whatever it takes to get the job done. She worked hard selling a tiny little property I inherited, so when it came time to sell my McMansion lI trusted her and she came through with a solid sale. Hire her.

Home Seller in Canterbury

Stacey is the best realtor I’ve worked with, and that’s after having worked with six during my lifetime. From the beginning, Stacey has consistently placed our needs before her own, despite our frequent bouts of indecision and multiple hiccups in our lengthy home buying process. Stacey never pushed us into anything for the sake of expedience and stuck with us even while we made some bad decisions (later rectified by home inspections... phew!). We took an extremely long time to find our home, and Stacey never once rushed us. Her countless hours, weekend “tours” and “counseling sessions” will never be forgotten. I highly recommend Stacey for her professionalisms, loyalty, attention to needs, and friendly, positive attitude.

Home Buyer in Old Saybrook

Stacey made the buying process so easy for me. I would highly recommend her to any first-time home buyer. She explained everything thoroughly and always kept me in the loop. I closed on time and was able to use people she recommended for my financing and closing proceedings. Everything went  smoothly and there were no problems at all. Not one bad thing to say about the entire process. I even made a new friend in the process :) Thanks Stacey!!!

Home Buyer in Niantic

My son was moving from Los Angeles to Connecticut following a divorce and he and I decided to buy a house together.Stacey was absolutely wonderful in helping us make this difficult transition. She patiently provided extensive tours of available properties throughout Southeastern CT explaining the significant differences in each area. With her capable assistance my son and I finally found a perfect home for our needs and budget. In purchasing the property, Stacey was wealth of knowledge about all aspects of home purchasing including financing, taxes, home inspection, insurance, and closing attorneys. Following the preliminary building inspection she was even able to negotiated a credit from the seller for several items noted in the inspection. With her advice and assistance we were able to go to closing on the property in just a little over three weeks … much faster than expected. It was a real pleasure to work with Stacey and we would highly recommend her to anyone coming to this area.

Home Buyer in Norwich

This was my first time buying a house on my own and Stacey was awesome. She was honest with me when we looked at houses and was patient with me while I was waiting for the closing on my former home. I would absolutely recommend Stacey to anyone looking to purchase their home.

New Home Buyer in East Lyme

We contacted Stacey to sell our home based our her familiarity with the area and recommendations from others. Stacey met with us and proved that she was very knowledgeable on homes in our price range and what to expect on the sale of our house. She was professional and noted the we should expect  our home to sell fast, so be prepared. Her predication turned out to be true; we sold our house less than 24 hours after the listing posted. After the sale of the house Stacey was there to provide assistance with the home inspections and other services. She was there to help while we were traveling out of state to find a new house, even helping take care of our dogs so the inspector could view the house. Stacey went above and beyond to help us. I would highly recommend using Stacey for the sale of your house.

Home Seller in Niantic

Stacey recently helped me through a new home purchase for me and my two children. She quickly was able to recognize what listings were a good fit for me and the needs of my family. Stacey was also extremely professional in assisting me with rescinding an offer where the sellers were not willing  to negotiate septic repairs further. I would highly recommend Stacey to anyone interested in purchasing a home. Her knowledge of the area and timely communication made this house buying experience enjoyable.

Home Buyer East Lyme

Stacey is a very professional, patient and knowledgeable realtor. Used her as a buyers agent to find a home. Would absolutely use her in the future to buy and/or sell. She responds quickly and swiftly to all questions and requests, and was a great resource acting on my behalf. Was able to grab  opportunities and go after the sellers aggressively when needed. Will recommend her to others!

Home buyer in Oakdale

Stacey was amazing throughout the whole process. Gave us honest input as to what was needed to be done and what not to waste time and money on. Kept us updated about everything and sold our house FAST and at the profit we were looking for. She even accommodated our needs as we were moving out of  state and on a tight schedule, she made it happen, A++, would recommend Stacey to anyone looking to sell or buy.

Home Seller in East Lyme

Stacey was wonderful. Not only did she help us market and sell our home, she helped us buy our dream home! She has great resources and references for trades people, including painters, contractors, home inspectors, attorneys, etc. We would highly recommend Stacey to anyone looking to buy or sell a  home in CT.

Home Seller & Buyer in East Lyme

Stacey is an excellent realtor. Her schedule was very flexible which allowed us to see several houses prior to finding our perfect home. At each house she took the time to identify our needs and preferences in order to help find a home. We found working with Stacey to be a wonderful  experience. She was very knowledgeable, honest and responsive to our needs. My fiance and I highly recommend her!

Home Buyer in Colchester

We met Stacey when she showed us a house that one of the principal brokers in her office listed. Although that house wasn't right for us, she helped us find the right one. She worked with our schedule since we were out of town. She was always on time and cheerful. Stacey is a delight. She was also  the only broker we met who followed up with us. I would recommend her wholeheartedly.

Home buyer in Waterford

Stacey help my husband and I find an income rental property. Stacey went to multiple properties with us because we had a hard time choosing where would be best. She helped educate us on a process we had no idea about and took our calls any time of day. She even helped us months after we got the  house and she already had her commission. We had actually used few realtors until we met Stacey and now we wouldn't use anyone else.

Investment Buyer in Groton

Stacey is a great realtor! She keeps your needs and preferences at the top of her list when she's showing places. She saved us time by crossing off a few places that she could tell would be money-pits. I felt like I was in great hands having her as our leader and negotiator! Thanks Stacey!

Home buyer in Baltic

We found that working with Stacey turned out to be a wonderful experience when we came to sell our home and purchase a new one. She was very knowledgeable, honest and responsive to our needs. My wife and I highly recommend her.

Luxury Home Seller in Old Saybrook | Home Buyer in Essex

Stacey Wyeth has been very proactive in listing and selling our Home. She is very knowledgeable in all aspects in the current market and was very helpful in us getting the home sold quickly and her our asking price. We would recommend her to anybody!

Home seller in Colchester

Stacey was a pleasure to work with. She was very prompt handling the myriad of tasks that come with selling a house. Her suggestions helped us put our best foot forward when showing the house. She was also very patient and resourceful when problems and questions came up. I highly recommend her!

Home seller in Salem

This was the first home that I have purchased and Stacy was extremely helpful through the entire process. She made herself available both on the phone, emails and home visits to accommodate my crazy schedule. She was knowledgeable about the process and she was great at negotiating. I would  definitely use her in the future and would recommend her to anyone.

Home buyer in Colchester

Stacey helped us find our dream home. She was very helpful in negotiating and was always available to answer questions. I highly recommend her for all your real estate needs. She is the best! :)

Home buyer in Oakdale

Stacey Wyeth is an amazing realtor! When she and I first met by phone we immediately clicked, Stacey was attentive to detail and was ready immediately to get to work for our family. Stacey is the most family oriented professional I've met in a very long time, being excited to start looking for  hikes with us in the middle of the winter and during that process bonding with our then 6 month old son. Stacey's kindness and professionalism were one of a kind and I have recommended her to several family members and friends. Thank you for everything again Stacey.

Home buyer in Colchester

Stacey helped me find a great new home. She was very helpful in negotiating small details and always available to answer questions. I highly recommend her for all your real estate needs.

Home buyer in Niantic

Stacey was a huge help in the whole process, she helped with recommendations of lenders, and inspectors, she was there with me every step of the way, she really made the whole experience wonderful and stress free for me. I will be recommending her to anyone I know of looking for a new home.

Home Buyer in Niantic

Stacey went above and beyond with helping me find the perfect house in Connecticut. I was moving up from VA and having only met my wife one time, she was able to help me find a house that would meet my wifes' expectations. She was extremely knowledgeable with all the towns I was looking at and  explained along the way which towns would best suite my family needs. She explained the buying process for me in detail so I would understand each step along the way. Stacey was also able to go to the house for me during inspections and let the contractors in when I couldn't make it. She never lost patience with me even after the 15 house I looked at. I was a zillow beast wanting to look at every house I saved as one of my favorites, but quickly learned houses look A LOT different in pictures than in person. Thank you Stacey! I wish I could use your services once again, but I don't plan on moving anytime soon seeing as we found the perfect home!

Home Buyer/Relocation in Colchester

Stacey goes above and beyond realtors call of duty, getting my paperwork into the lender, scrambling her schedule minute by minute to show me places and even insisted that she drive us together to go look at listings even when I had a nasty cold I did not want to sneeze in her car but she paid that  no mind, I am writing this on my phone and the star ratings above do not seem to be working, working with other realtors who always seemed to have some smart aleck remark to make if I did not make an immediate offer on a place was not the case with Stacey, she is the most patient person I have ever met!

Home Buyer in Waterford

Stacey made the process of buying my very first home informative and painless. Helping me narrow down my location and the type of home would work best for me. She answered my numerous questions and made everything clear and also provided lots of tidbits of information along the way. It was a  pleasure working with Stacey and would do so again in the future

New home buyer in Norwich

Attentive, answered all questions, personable and great to work with!!! Thank you!

Home Seller in Preston

Stacey has helped me with a very difficult home purchase which has taken more than a year. Unflagging, cheerful, knowledgeable--she is the kind of person you want with you, especially when events conspire to put hurdle after hurdle in your path; she gets you through it all. Stacey coordinates well  with all the other players involved (lawyers, mortgage brokers, etc.) and turns it into a team effort.

Home buyer in Niantic

Stacey was absolutely outstanding to work with. She went above and beyond the typical realtor line of work. She got to know my entire family by name and even played with my little one while we looked at houses. She would call or email as soon as houses that fit what we were looking for came onto the market. I would recommend Stacey to anyone who would like a stress and hassle free home buying experience!

Home Buyer in Salem

Stacey helped me sell my father's home after he passed away. I had so much to deal with in his passing that selling the house was the last thing I wanted to deal with but Stacey made the process easy. She was extremely sensitive to my grief and walked me through the home selling process like a pro!  She explained everything and answered all of my questions. Now the house is sold and I can move on to the next step. Thank you Stacey Wyeth for the outstanding professional service!

Home Seller - Niantic CT

"As someone who is young and uneducated on real estate, Stacey set everything up for me and took the time to explain whatever I asked! She was patient and listened to what I wanted in my first home! Even a few months after the sale went through Stacey stayed in contact making sure it was everything I ever wanted! She made sure to steer me clear of bad deals and was honest when asked for an opinion on a home! A great realtor and person overall! Loved working with her’"

Brittany Meyer

Stacey was great throughout the entire process. She knows alot about the area and knew exactly the type of home I was looking for and things that I should avoid. She has alot of knowledge about what to look for in a home and things that would need to be done if purchased or before moving in, which  helped me make the best decision. Stacey was easy to reach throughout the process and would immediately have the answers or find the answers for the many questions I had right away. I recommend Stacey to any type of buyer.

Home buyer in Salem

Stacey went above and beyond for us during our house hunting and buying process, as we were shopping during the winter months, even the snow didn't stop her. She listened to what we wanted and found answers for anything we wanted to know .She is very personal and dedicated. We highly recommend her!

Home buyer in Oakdale

From listed to SOLD in a month!!!! Smooth process! No one better than Stacey Wyeth!!! Highly Recommend if you are buying or selling!!!! She kept me in the loop every step of the way, always accommodating with showings and feedback and all the little details!!

Home Seller in Gales Ferry

My Listings

85 Sullivan Road $298,000 link

85 Sullivan Road

Salem, CT 06420 | New London County
4 Beds 2 Baths 2,040 Sqft 1.5 Acres

HIGHEST AND BEST DUE BY 12/11 AT 9 pm Welcome home to 85 Sullivan Rd. Salem! There is room for everyone in this 4/5 bedroom country classic Cape Cod located on 1.5 private acres...

3 Honeysuckle Lane $317,000 link

3 Honeysuckle Lane

East Lyme, CT 06357 | New London County
2 Beds 2/1 Baths 1,609 Sqft

Welcome to easy living in the heart of Niantic. This well-maintained home is located in the desirable 55+ community of Chapman Farms. Move-in ready with an open floor plan, offering...


My Sales

363 Maple Avenue $1,125,000 link

363 Maple Avenue

Old Saybrook, CT 06475 | Middlesex County
4 Beds 4/1 Baths 3,718 Sqft 0.68 Acres

One-of-a-kind direct waterfront property with 335 feet of water frontage on Long Island Sound with spectacular, panoramic views from almost every room. Situated high above the...

19 Jeremy Drive $785,000 link

19 Jeremy Drive

East Lyme, CT 06333 | New London County
4 Beds 4/1 Baths 4,492 Sqft 1.29 Acres

HIGHEST AND BEST BY WEDNESDAY MARCH 3rd- 6PM. Welcome home to 19 Jeremy Drive in the desirable neighborhood of Deans Ridge, located in the heart of East Lyme, just minutes to the...

19 Bayview Avenue $750,000 link

19 Bayview Avenue

East Lyme, CT 06357 | New London County
5 Beds 2/1 Baths 2,232 Sqft 0.11 Acres

Until recently described as a Colonial Beach Cottage, this C1920 5 Bed 2.5 bath home with wonderful views of Long Island Sound and nearby Beach, is now an all season, pristine,...

30 East Shore Drive $680,000 link

30 East Shore Drive

East Lyme, CT 06357 | New London County
3 Beds 2 Baths 1,339 Sqft 0.13 Acres

Summer is here but there is plenty of time left to enjoy your own beach house in Black Point! Dont miss this opportunity to move into this 3/4 bd home with plenty of space for...

12 Beach Drive $639,000 link

12 Beach Drive

Stonington, CT 06355 | New London County
3 Beds 1/1 Baths 1,728 Sqft 0.17 Acres

Perfect location on private road with marvelous water views and sunsets that will amaze you. Remodeled contemporary house in excellent condition with delightful open floor plan...

17 Rose Lane $570,000 link

17 Rose Lane

East Lyme, CT 06333 | New London County
4 Beds 4 Baths 4,005 Sqft 1.2 Acres

This well-appointed home sits back off the road on 1.2 acres in a quiet neighborhood and offers you plenty of space for everyone. You will love the entertaining space of the large...

42 Attawanhood Trail $565,000 link

42 Attawanhood Trail

Old Saybrook, CT 06475 | Middlesex County
3 Beds 2/1 Baths 1,656 Sqft 0.14 Acres

Pride of ownership obvious here - a decorator's delight. 3 bedroom 2.1 bath home situated just a short stroll from the beach at Indian Town Beach Association. Privileges include...