Amy Kirst

Amy Kirst

Real Estate Salesperson

Amy Kirst
  • M
696 Boston Post Road
Madison, CT 06443

About Me About Me

In real estate, it is the accountability, the one on one connection between you and your client, that makes you successful. Clients that work with Amy Kirst will appreciate her enthusiasm, integrity, knowledge of the area as well as her command of the market. A Madison native, Amy has been a top producer for many years, selling homes from Branford to Old Lyme, and inland from Killingworth to Deep River. If you ask her why she is so successful, she will tell you that it is easy to sell homes in areas that you love. "These towns offer so much to those who live in them..a lifestyle, communities that care about their residents and small town quaintness and warmth." Amy enjoys working with new clients, and appreciates the repeat business and referrals from past clients calling her again to sell their home, purchase a new one or both. She feels that communication with clients is paramount, not only for business but also because she cares about their happiness and quality of life. Amy originally started out as a biochemist but felt that she was more of a "people person"; she ventured into real estate through the urging of a prominent real estate lawyer and has never looked back. Amy is married to a builder that builds and renovates homes on the shoreline. She has four children that have grown up in Madison; two graduating from Hand High School, one from Choate and one from Taft. A consistent multi-million dollar producer, Amy has always ranked in the top percentage of agents for homes sold and has received numerous awards for her performance throughout her career. She is a member of the National Association of Realtors, the Connecticut Association of Realtors, as well as the New Haven Middshore Association of Realtors.

  • Born In New Haven, CT
  • Lives In Madison, CT
  • Favorite Movie Goodwill Hunting
  • Passion Love the snow, wintertime, outdoor activties
  • Interests Animals -especially dogs and ice Yale games and any live game I can attend that my family members play in
  • Favorite Lyric "When writing the story about your life, don't let anyone else hold the pen"
  • Inspiration My Mother...she was a beautiful soul.
  • Can't Live Without My Family.....sometimes they drive me crazy but I just adore them.

My Awards

  • Top Producer on the Shoreline for the past 21 plus years.
Amy Kirst photo 1
Amy Kirst photo 2
Amy Kirst photo 3
Amy Kirst photo 4
Amy Kirst photo 5
Amy Kirst photo 6
Amy Kirst photo 7
Amy Kirst photo 8
Amy Kirst photo 9
Amy Kirst photo 10
Amy Kirst photo 11
Amy Kirst photo 12
Amy Kirst photo 13
Amy Kirst photo 14
Amy Kirst photo 15

My Listings and Sales

Loading listings...

Testimonials (18)

Amy was incredibly professional, knowledgeable, experienced, helpful, available and all things that make her an agent that I would both highly recommend using and use again. Catherine Peru
Our agent was knowledgeable and professional and worked very hard for us. Robert & Jean Blouin
I had the best experience. Amy Kirst is an amazing agent, and an even better person. I couldn’t have been happier trusting her and her team on the sale of our home. Richard & Vanessa Federico
Amy is a pleasure to work with. She has a lot of experience and is extremely knowledgeable about the market. We recommend her highly! BB
As a first time homebuyer, Amy went the extra mile to help me feel confident in my purchase. She’s down to earth and honest. That’s extremely hard to find nowadays. Erica Brancato
Amy has helped us with several home sales in Guilford over the past 15 years. She’s always honest, dedicated and thoughtful of your needs throughout the entire process. She stays calm in stressful moments, offers sound advice and is fair. She truly goes above and beyond for her clients. Her many years of experience has made her one of the best realtors in the area. She’s the real deal. Jim and Donna Brancato
Having worked with Amy Kirst on both the purchase and sale of homes in Madison, we have been absolutely thrilled with the results of our endeavor/s. Amy has repeatedly demonstrated her knowledge of the market, professionalism throughout the process and an uncanny ability to present homes in their most advantageous beauty. The true test of one’s opinion of Amy is our willingness to recommend that person to others. We have recommended Amy to both our immediate family and friends. All have found Amy to be professional, knowledgeable and highly successful in meeting their objective. She has earned and deserves the highest praise that we could possibly provide. Eric and Lorrie Petersen
Amy is the consummate professional. We always felt she was looking after our best interests as buyers new to the Shoreline. Amy was always accessible, presented opportunities she thought we’d be interested in, willing to offer her opinion, and a pleasure to work with. Frank & Deirdre Frank Donnantuono
Amy could not have represented us better on our recent sale. She is extremely knowledgeable about the market, thorough, and hard working. Her experience and judgment made a big difference throughout the process - from giving us great advice about how best to position our listing, to how best to respond to the offers we received. We could not be happier. Marvin Pestcoe
Amy Kirst marketed and sold our house for us in a short time frame in summer 2021. Throughout the process, Amy was a dependable source of expertise, immense experience, and practical advice. Among other things, Amy has the benefit of a considerable local network and was able to put us in touch with local specialists when we had to do some unexpected repairs. We felt guided and supported and appreciated Amy's combination of human warmth, professionalism, and humor. It was truly a pleasure working with Amy. David Milne and Emily Milne
Amy was instrumental in helping us finalize and purchase our home. She brought an expertise to the process that few can match. She was able to dial in on the finer details of all of the homes we visited that helped us look at the homes from a very practical perspective. She was excellent at pointing out important details like the age and quality of mechanicals, appliances and other items that could have easily been overlooked. She did an excellent job of removing the blinders from some of the houses that looked great at first glance but may have had issues shortly after purchase. She was never shy about asking for more details on items that may have been concealed at first glance by the sellers. Her honest, practical approach gave us the piece of mind that we were making the right decision on either passing on a home or ultimately purchasing the home we did. I would be hard pressed to find someone who could represent us as well as Amy did. Whenever I hear of anyone looking to buy a home I can confidently say Amy is the best in the business! Andrew
I have worked with Amy for a number of years on multiple real estate transactions. Amy is the ultimate professional, she understands the market whether I am selling or purchasing and her attention to detail is exceptional. Being a longtime general contractor I understand and appreciate timely communication and Amy has always been excellent at keeping me informed. I would certainly give her a five star rating and strongly recommend anyone thinking of a real estate transaction to contact Amy. Thomas Gilloran
Amy was fabulous throughout the entire process from selling to buying and all aspects of the move. She is smart, pays attention to detail and is the ultimate professional . Simply stated Amy made the transition a pleasure. Jerry and Cathy Kerins
Amy masterfully navigated the sale of our family home. Her advice was spot on, honest and well informed. As we were four siblings selling an inherited property, Amy’s expertise and diplomacy gave us the peace of mind that our decisions during this process were well received. From listing to closing she kept us well informed. Our recommendation comes without hesitation! Paul and Betsy Bierkan
we have sold many homes in our lives ,Amy Kirts was the best ,most caring ,hardest working , agent we have worked with. We would not hesitate to work with her again. Paul Chagnon
We truly enjoyed working with Amy. Her advice was spot on when we put our house on the market. She is a seasoned professional! Jill Russo
I have the upmost respect for Amy - she is the consumate professional with astute business sense. And - she is kind and genuine. It has been my sincere pleasure to work with her. Jean & Robin Vuillermet
Amy did a fantastic job! She made a big difference. John & Catherine Cocco

Amy Kirst in the News


Classic Colonial Living…

Shoreline Times

Former sea captain’s home in Old Saybrook…

The New York Times

What’s Selling Now: Homes That Sold for Around $450,000 – Connecticut…

Shoreline Times

‘A step back in time’ at antique 1910 Madison beach home…

Luxury Homes

From @WilliamPittSIR in #Guilford, Connecticut…

Contact Me

  • Amy Kirst

    Amy Kirst

    Real Estate Salesperson
  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.