Susan McDonnell

Susan McDonnell

Licensed Real Estate Salesperson

Susan McDonnell
  • M
49 Purchase Street
Rye, NY 10580

Overall Sales Volume

Properties Sold

Last Year's Sales Volume

About Me About Me

A lifelong resident of Westchester, Susan McDonnell has over 20 years of experience in the real estate industry, specializing in the communities of Rye, Harrison, Purchase, Rye Brook, Port Chester, and White Plains.  Her strong ties to the community, in-depth knowledge of the local real estate market, and commitment to providing a high level of personal service are among the attributes she brings to her clients.  With expertise in all aspects of the real estate market, she is adept at working with home buyers and sellers as well as those who are renting or relocating throughout the U.S. and abroad.

Dedicated to helping sellers achieve success and buyers find their perfect home, Susan is known for her integrity, professionalism, and attention to detail as well for her caring personality.  Her strengths as a skilled negotiator help her clients navigate all the complex transactions involved in real estate purchases and sales.  Having played an active role in the local schools during her children’s education, she is also a well-versed source of information on the area’s public and private schools.  The trust and respect Susan has earned from her clients have brought her many repeat customers and referrals.

Susan is a member of the National Association of Realtors, New York State Association of Realtors, Westchester Putnam Board of Realtors, and Rye/Harrison Multiple Listing Service.  Prior to her career in real estate, she was an educator in a New York City school.  A graduate of Boston College, with a B.A. in psychology, she also holds an M.S. in teaching from Fordham University.  Actively involved in the community, Susan volunteers for many charitable organizations including My Sisters’ Place and the Hospice of Westchester. 

  • Born In New york
  • Lives In Harrison

Agent Designations

  • Licensed Real Estate Salesperson

My Awards

  • Westchester Magazine 2023 Best Real Estate Agent

My Specialties

  • Elite Sports Network Member

My Listings and Sales

Loading listings...

Testimonials (13)

Susan was excellent in handling our sale and purchase. We were 100% sarisfied. Brian and Mary Leeney Brian and Eileen M. Leeney
Susan was essential to us in finding our new home. We are first time home buyers, and Susan guided us step by step through the entire process. Her guidance, support and expertise helped us navigate an extremely difficult and volatile market for homebuyers. We are so grateful to have had her in our corner and relied on her knowledge of the area and seasoned experience as a broker to find our dream home. She is the absolute best and was so wonderful to work with. Meg & Ken LeStrange
Working with Susan McDonnell was a joy. Susan sold my home in record time, found me a furnished rental with my dog while the condominium she found for me to buy was being built. I could not be happier. Susan McDonnell is the utmost professional as well as a most caring person regarding her clients. I recommend her highly . Nancy Curry
Working with Susan McDonnell is a pleasure. She is the ultimate professional . Nancy Curry O'Shaughnessy
susan is wonderful Izabela Reszko
We have been lucky enough to have Susan as our RE Broker and Advisor for the purchase of three homes and sale of two. Susan is known for her competency and integrity. We consider Susan a trusted friend and an amazing RE Advisor. She is a warm, genuine person who treats all clients like family. We have come to trust Susan with the most complex and delicate of tasks without hesitation. She embodies teamwork and excels at attention to detail. Rye, NY
Sue was extremely helpful and knowledgeable about Westchester, she helped guide us towards the right neighborhood and home that we have grown to love. I highly suggest Sue to anyone that is looking for a top notch real estate agent! Port Chester
Thank you Susan for finding us our dream home! Your ability to narrow down the search to THE house that checks all our wish list boxes, the frequent updates, quick responses and your very pleasant, flexible and friendly way of working was truly enjoyable! Harrison, NY
Susan guided us through every step of purchasing our first home. Her honesty, knowledge, experience and promptness are unmatched. Susan defines class and we are very grateful for her guidance both during and after the sale. Harrison, NY
Susan was great to work with! She understood what we were looking for within our price range. Very knowledgeable in all things real estate. I would highly recommend her to all family and friends. A complete pro!! Harrison, NY
Working with Susan McDonnell has always been a pleasure. Susan takes incredible care of her clients, and never is too busy to help show you a property, answer dozens of questions, or offer her expert professional advise in a housing situation. Buying and selling your home can be incredibly stressful, and Susan takes all the stress out of the experience, and makes all her clients feel they are a priority. We could not be more pleased with her as our broker. Her experience, reputation, and good nature are unsurpassed! Harrison, NY
Susan McDonnell has helped our family successfully find the perfect home. Most recently she helped our son and daughter in law purchase their first home. She can accommodate all budgets, big or small and is an expert in the field with a long, professional knowledge of the Westchester area, particularly Rye NY. Susan is a good negotiator and can recommend good lawyers, inspectors, insurance agents... to complete your purchase with peace of mind. Her best quality is honesty and integrity. I would highly recommend Susan McDonnell to find your next home! Rye, NY
Susan McDonnell has been our Real Estate Agent for the past 15 years. My wife and I have relied on her professionalism and extensive knowledge through the entire process with our purchase of 3 homes. Susan is friendly, insightful and was always available to answer any questions we had. Ann and I recommend her entirely. Harrison, NY

Additional Communities

White Plains
Port Chester

Susan McDonnell in the News

The Rye Record

On the Home Front: 365 Grace Church St., Rye…

Westchester Magazine

On the Market: An Elegant and Refined Purchase Contemporary…

Harrison Herald

Trust of Late Julia B. Fee Sotheby’s International Realty Agent Donates Funds to My Sisters’…

Rye Record

Trust of Late Julia B. Fee Sotheby’s International Realty Agent Donates Funds to My Sisters’…

Contact Me

  • Susan McDonnell

    Susan McDonnell

    Licensed Real Estate Salesperson
  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.